Voting is a Tactic Not the Solution

15–23 minutes

read

An image of a blue envelope featuring the text 'Voting is a Tactic Not the Solution' in bold red letters, and a note stating 'Your ballot will arrive by October 19'.

First, I will pay homage and respect to our predecessors and ancestors over the generations who fought and struggled, who were beaten, humiliated and killed so that many of us could have the right to vote today, myself included. The stories of Fanny Lou Hamer, Anne Moody, Rosa Parks, Harriot Tubman, Sojourner Truth, Ida B. Wells, W.E.B. DuBois, Booker T. Washington, Frederick Douglass, Malcom X, Reverend Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., Medgar Evers, Bob Zellner, Bernard Lafayette, Bayard Rustin, Elizabeth Cady Stanton, Susan B. Anthony, Ella Baker, and so, so many more who are known to us because of their writings and the writings of other people about them and their efforts. I also pay respect to the countless many over the generations who do not come down to us named, who dealt with poll taxes, and writing tests, who had to suffer any of innumerable humiliations, insults, assaults, or murder while attempting to vote or even to register to vote. We have a long and rich legacy around us, and none of that is lost on me as I write this today. Their stories are part of the arc of stories that make up the amerikkkan story of colonization and conquest, enslavement and exploitation, resistance to oppression and the faith that a better and more just world is possible.

Voting and other forms of collective decision making are the path to the equitable future so many of us are fighting for today. In fact, I believe that collective decision making that is more horizontal in nature is the decision making structure of the future we desire and deserve. The faith that a better and more just world is possible has not vanished, although it may have morphed over time, as well as more or less bravely expressed, depending on the circumstances. Nonetheless, the soul of justice is still very much alive in the people of the world, let alone the united snakes. Often, when we think about disenfranchisement the thoughts or discussions that occur center on presidential or national elections and while important, I think that local decisions about schools; roads; parks; utilities like electricity, water, sewage, trash, recycle, and compost; municipal ordinances and state laws; taxes and public money budgets; and the like play a much bigger role in how we all normally experience and feel life. It is also not a forgotten point that int he U.S., if a person is not on the voter rolls that they also cannot serve on a jury, and for so long as that is the case, then a jury of our peers is impossible for way too many of us. Like voting, when most people think about courts and juries they are thinking about “criminal” cases, and while that is very important–and I will touch on some of that later–there are also Tort or Civil cases that touch most of the rest of the aspects of our lives that are also impacted by this.

The point is that collective decision making is an essential evolution of society, or rather should I say, remembering of society. Humankind is not a solitary species, we are communal and social. Our history, whether written, oral, or forgotten and lost to us is complex and messy, and while it may be easy to romanticize any group of people from any time or place imagining that there were no faults in praxis, nonetheless, it is also true, that collective decision making has been part of the social dynamic. Even when there has been a tyrant or despot; a queen or a captain on a ship; a chief, shaman, elder; a CEO or a president; or what have you that seemed to have absolute decision making power over a people if we delved deeply enough into the reality it would quickly become apparent that the “absolute decision making power” was merely an illusion as they only had and kept that illusion for so long as the people collectively chose to uphold it.

I name the above so that what I am about to say is not conflated or misconstrued as my harboring some belief that collective decision making, which may include casting votes is not good, or meaningful, or that I am suggesting that anyone not vote. In fact, I am arguing the exact opposite of that, vote and participate in collective decision making as often as you can. Rights, as we understand them, are neither inherent, nor are they inalienable as some of our predecessors have claimed. Rights as we understand them are fought for and won, and if and when they are not exercised, then they are taken back. Our predecessors did not ‘vote’ their way into voting, nor did they merely wish they would magically have the right to vote, they fought for it in countless ways, one of which was exercising their right to vote. Most of the (his/her/their)-story that is handed down to us and taught to us in schools is not only white-washed, but pacifist-washed. It is true that many of our ancestors and predecessors took a high moral ground and exploited the violence of their oppressors and subjugators by choosing to not fight back when attacked, electing the path of “non-violence” as a key strategy. That National Association for the Advancement of Colored People (NAACP), the Congress of Racial Equality (CORE), the Southern Christian Leadership Conference, and the Student Nonviolent Coordinating Committee (SNCC), among others exemplify this. And, like the quote from Malcom X from the Nation of Islam suggests, “the ballot or the bullet,” there were many many, like Harriot Tubman, Robert F. Williams, the Black Panther Party for Self Defense, the American Indian Movement, and the Deacons for Defense and Justice who took a very much different approach. However, regardless of the approach one thing is clear, none of them were fooled into thinking that the right to vote was magically going to appear. They knew unequivocally that they not only had to define the Right, but that they also had to carve it out, and defend the space they made.

Which brings me to the reason for this article, namely, that voting is a tactic, it is not a solution. It pains me to both see and to experience the vast amount of people who believe that voting is the answer or solution and that we just need more people to vote, like that will solve all of our problems. Or worse yet, the belief that they have done their part because they voted, full stop. There is much crossover between the two paradigms and the net outcome is that once voting is complete, the vast majority of people leave the rest of the decision making and follow-through on commitments to others. Are you among the many who are upset about the proliferation of data centers or Immigration & Customs Enforcement (I.C.E.) interment camps, or the Department of Homeland Security and the Patriot Act, the massive expansion of the dystopian panopticon and the mass surveillance apparatus with platforms like Mobile Fortify (a database that has over 200 million people’s identities) which ICE deploys in our communities, and which the Department of Government Efficiency (D.O.G.E.) via Elon Musk and Palantir helped to create, and so on? Well, so many people merely voting alone is part of what helped make all of those things possible. Voting is a tactic and an important one, but that cannot be all that we do. That will not get us to the place we are trying to go, as the evidence reveals.

It boggles my mind how many times my predictions have come to pass, but I suppose that I should stop being surprised at this point because I have grown into a wise and perceptive analytical strategist. I remember writing a speech for a May Day protest a few years back titled, “Fascism Rising,” and my co-organizers thought that I was reaching, if not baseless in my assertions. And now look at what is going on. The trump administration is systematically going after and hunting down dissenters whether in the streets, the media, or candidates and elected officials. Case in point, the raid on Minnesota Representative Ilhan Omar’s home on October 12, 2026 mere weeks before the mid-term elections. This is unheard of and is absurd to the maximum. A radical (for someone elected to office), powerful, educated, and respected black woman with a platform who opposes the unilateral usurpation of the democratic process the current administration is practicing was perceived as a threat and thus was removed from the board. While this is not new as a practice as history conveys–Malcom X, MLK, Leonard Peltier, Assata Shakur, Watergate, etc…–it is nonetheless a blatant and explicit radical shift of using the state to remove opposition. Yet another high profile example was when Washington Post reporter, Hannah Natanson’s home was raided by federal agents who seized laptops, phones, and smart watches on January 14, 2026. Again, this was unheard of and yet, even after the insult to democracy, not much was done to interfere with or stop the trajectory of this fascist administration. Throughout this term of trump’s presidency, the right of the people to peaceably assemble and to petition the government for grievances rendered has been violated time and time again. In Minnesota after Renee Good and Alex Pretti were killed by ICE agents and unto this point seem to have gotten away with it, trump initiated Operation Puppet Master–I swear, we don’t have to make this shit up–illegally spying on and investigating individuals, groups, non-profit organizations, and unions with everything from undercover agents, to tailing operations, to the Social Media Exploitation Program aka S.O.M.E.X., to requisitioning financial records, and tapping people’s devices, and this is what we know about. Additionally, they have been increasing the application and definition of conspiracy charges and domestic terrorism charges, and they are winning cases against people who are defending our communities from tyrants and despots. Not that I am for police or militaries or state power, but as a historian and analyst there was a time when the word “terrorist” had a meaning and a definition. Yet, over the last quarter century since 9-11, but especially over the last few years a “terrorist” has become anyone, anywhere, at anytime who disagrees with trump. Both Renee Good and Alex Pretti were slandered by Kristi Noem, then head of Homeland Security, as being terrorists moments after they were killed. A legal observer and a street medic were labeled and classified as terrorist, and that story was sold to the amerikkkan public. The current targets of this fascist agenda are people of color, people of the LGBTQIA+ community, people who have been impoverished, and people who have been compelled to migrate and immigrate largely because of messes this government has created.

Something that is currently vexing me and it is strange that I am not hearing or reading about anyone else thinking about this, is what is happening to the U.S. military. Pete Hegseth, in the role Minister of War, a position formerly known as Secretary of Defense (this should tell us everything we need to know), has systematically be removing from both the ranks and leadership all opposition, and has been working to transform the Department of Defense into a monolithic, masculine, testosterone infested machine. On the coattails of the January 6th Insurrection–all of who participated have now been pardoned or otherwise exonerated by this administration and who almost received an asinine payout as part of an illegal court settlement about the Treasury Department doing it’s job investigating tax fraud, called the “anti-weaponization fund” at $1.776 billion (1,776 the year the American Revolution was won)–that trump wanted because he would not concede that he lost the election to Joe Biden; it is very concerning that a military in bed with mega-wealthy tech oligarchs has been turned into monolithic trump supporting regime. These are the quintessential ingredients of a coup and no one is talking about it.

Everyone is focused on the mid-term elections like the rest of our lives hinge on this one particular moment. This is one of the reasons that I was so concerned with the “No Kings” rallies and marches and Indivisible in general, but once I learned that Indivisible is an offshoot of the Democratic Party itself being formed post a letter being sent from them after trump was first elected in 2016, it all began to make sense. On the one hand, the No Kings rallies and marches galvanized the anger of a nation and pulled together some of the largest opposition protests that have ever been seen. On the other hand, it also neutered the anger and the energy of the nation by insinuating, if not outright declaring that all that was needed was to march for one day and to vote. However, assuming that I have all of this correct, and assuming for a moment that Republican Party control of the Senate and House who are kowtowing cowards, and that Democratic Party control would yield a different outcome; it still cannot be understated that the Democratic Party is just as responsible for the system of mass incarceration; the proliferation of private prisons with the amplification and platforming of CoreCivic and GEO Group who are now running almost all of the immigration internment camps across the country; that Obama deported more people during his terms than trump did during his first term; that Biden among other Democrats were part of the Patriot Act, the development of the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) and ICE, and was part of the decisions to invade both Iraq and Afghanistan; that Obama was the first to institute the use of the drone strike that trump is now rampantly using to bomb random boats in the Pacific Ocean, Gulf of Mexico, and Caribbean Sea; and that both Palantir and Elon Musk’s companies were made during the timeline just mapped out by doing business with the federal government. In short and on measure, how is the Democratic Party functionally any different than the Republican Party?

There was a time when the government would not get involved with social issues, but then the Great Depression of the 1930’s happened and everything changed. This is when the institution of the Social Security Number was created, and it was promised in the deliberations and even the statutes that these numbers would not be used for tracking or financial reasons. We know how that panned out. Initially, they were a way of ensuring that everyone who needed food, supplies, and services could access them from the government. President Franklin Delano Roosevelt created so many social programs that his collection of terms in office have been referred to as “alphabet soup,” because of all the acronyms that added up. That was perhaps the U.S. has ever been to a socialist economy, aided in part by the U.S. entering into World War Two when domestic factories were turned into war machines. The U.S. went from a hands-off approach to most social issues to claiming ownership over addressing them; controlling them. Now a community cannot legally care for itself without being ‘licensed’ to do so by the government. In Phoenix, Arizona it is a crime for a person to feed those who are hungry and compelled to live on the street without a license, otherwise known as a food handlers permit, and permission to do. The irony is that the same government that is touted as being responsible for addressing social problems is also responsible for creating them. One example is that there were not be so much poverty if the wealth divide were addressed by regulating the businesses of the mega-wealthy, capping earnings and distributing wealth more equitably–this would go a long way toward addressing the incessant affordability and hunger crises. In large part, the government is inadequate to address and resolve social problems, and one reason for this is because they are too far removed from both the people and the problems themselves, then they also discount and disqualify those who are close to the problems from being part of the solutions.

It is long past time that we lay claim to our right to care for ourselves and our own communities. This is the philosophy that provides the foundation of the collection of activities and services known as Mutual Aid, that is, the grassroots and often gorilla care members of our community provide for other members of our community. Prisons and police are failed experiments in regard to solving social problems, but they are keen profit generators for the wealthy, so they keep being pushed onto us. This is why even when evidenced based, data driven, community controlled alternatives are available and capable the state side-lines them when it does not outright seek to crush them. Earlier, I named that Rights that are not exercised are Rights that are taken back, these are all prime examples of that conclusion. We have been trained to think that a ‘protest’ is people chanting and marching on the street, but I encourage you to expand your understanding of what a protest is. The mechanism of a protest is to draw into focus the inconsistencies of a situation until the dissonant frequencies become a crisis moment. In this context, what I am describing is to define and carve out the space for the rights we desire and deserve, the same way our predecessors and ancestors did, and then exercise those rights. The despot and the tyrant only have absolute decision making authority for so long as we choose to grant it to them. This in part means that we are responsible for our own hells and that we are responsible for concluding them.

We have two existential threats engulfing us right now that are interwoven with each other: Data Centers and the evolution of Artificial General Intelligence (AGI). AGI and the mega-wealthy tech oligarchs creating it with its innumerable applications present a tidal wave of potential cataclysmic outcomes for humanity; as does the unfathomably resource hungry and massively polluting data centers powering it. Holding constant that we have an obligation to our Indigenous relatives who are the stewards of these lands and our need to find a way to be in balance with their many Peoples; there was a time when collective ownership / stewardship of the land was the norm. We have been tricked into believing that collective anything is opposed to freedom and that freedom at the cost of everything and everyone else is the pinnacle of evolution, and as such, that collectivism is wrong and bad. I reject that notion. A major factor in why there is so much environmental degradation and how these tech oligarchs and big oil companies are able to gobble up all of the lands for their data centers is precisely because of the lack of collectivism, and is in direct correlation to how much individualism is contained within the system. Pushing back against the tyrannical system and claiming the lands, the water, the air, the fossils, etc… for all the people and holding them common-collective control in perpetuity wherein communities themselves determine how resources and lands will be used is the fight of our generation. I believe the outcome of this fight is the outcome that the rest of our lives are hinged up and perhaps the fate of humanity as well.

Voting will not win these fights. Watching the news or scrolling on social media will not win these fights. Joining the occasional parade will not win these fights. Being afraid to risk your comfort will not win these fights. Shutting down direct action, violent or not, and working with the state to hunt down and remove agitators will not win these fights. Endorsing another party who makes lavish promises but on measure has a record that cannot distinguish it will not win these fights. Waiting on others to liberate you will not win these fights. No, to win these fights we are going to have to risk everything because everything is at stake. We are going to have to risk our comfort and other collateral consequences to win these fights. We are going to have to revoke legitimacy from an illegitimate government to win these fights. We are going to have to find a way to resolve our differences and find ways to work together as we reclaim our lost Rights and claim new Rights. We are going to have to learn how to talk with and be in conflict with one another, so that we can grow into a state of collective decision making for us to win and sustain the victories of these fights. We have our work cut out for us.

Voting is a tactic, but it is not enough by itself, and it is not the solution. Voting is not a pass into absolution of responsibility, but it is very often a path to complicity. Those in power have set the agenda for us and this constricts the latitude of our options, for sure, but that does not mean we should not participate. Some ground is better than no ground. Our ancestors and predecessors fought, bled, and died so that we can vote today. We honor them and their sacrifices by doing so. We also have an obligation to our progeny to exercise our right to vote so that they too shall have the right to vote in the future. With all of the other fascist elements enumerated above, fascist governments the world over, the U.S. included, are systematically attacking voter roles and disenfranchising their opposition and any potential dissenters. This is not the time for passivity. If we are not alert, aware, and active the situation we find ourselves in will be much more dire and difficult to dig ourselves out from underneath.

ALL POWER TO THE PEOPLE


Discover more from Renaissance

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply